The Best Gutter Guards of 2024 (Tested)
Written by
When researching the best gutter guards for your home, you’ll find two types of products: professionally installed and do-it-yourself (DIY) options. We believe professional gutter guards are worth the price because they offer better overall quality and warranties. However, if the $4,000–$7,000 price tag is outside of your budget and you don’t mind some extra elbow grease, your best option is a DIY gutter guard.
Our team thoroughly researched 16 of the best DIY and professional gutter guard companies to help you make the right choice for your home. We consulted more than a dozen industry experts, surveyed 1,000 homeowners who have installed gutter guards, analyzed more than 1,000 customer reviews, and tested 12 brands firsthand. We scored each brand against our rigorous rating system, determining which professional installers offer the strongest combination of material and design, value, warranty coverage, customer reviews, services offered, and effectiveness. DIY guards don’t come with additional services, so we instead considered ease of installation when evaluating DIY products.
Five professional installers and five DIY products made our top rankings. The professional installers we recommend are national brands because they’re bigger and more established, so you’re more likely to have a successful project. If you prefer a local gutter guard installer, check out our guide to highly rated gutter guard companies near you. Keep in mind that going the DIY route involves ladder work, and serious injury is a risk. That said, if you have the right tools and know-how, DIY guards can be a cost-effective way to protect your gutters.
Compare Our Top 5 Professional Gutter Guard Companies
The following table compares our top picks for professional gutter guard companies based on their performance, price, and other key decision-making factors. We believe these are the five highest quality gutter guards available, but each product performs similarly well. Customer care, warranties, and the number of services offered are what really separate a “good” installer from a “great” one, so our review focuses on those details as much as possible.
Warranty Length
Filter Type
Sample Price
Pros
- Lifetime, transferable warranty
- Stainless steel micro-mesh guard that blocks small debris
- High customer review scores
- Manufactured in the U.S.
- Surgical-grade stainless steel mesh guards
- Range of additional services
- Unique raised-screen design for improved debris filtration
- Family-owned and operated
- Host of additional gutter services
- Lifetime no-clog guarantee
- Sturdy, single-piece reverse-curve gutter guard
- Durable ScratchGuard paint finish
- Reinforcing substructure for added durability
- Seamless aluminum gutters in 30 colors
- Several generous discounts
Cons
- No additional gutter services
- Reviews mention aggressive sales tactics
- Guards only come in one color
- No warranty details online
- Some customers report poor communication post-installation
- No pricing information online
- Guards not installable on existing gutters
- Prices exceed industry-standard cost
- Lower satisfaction rating than other brands
- No repair or cleaning services
Summary
We recommend LeafFilter. Its ultra-fine mesh guards outperform other products, blocking debris as small as shingle grit, pine needles, and pollen.
We recommend Gutter Guards America for homeowners looking for a reliable gutter guard installer with secure guarantees.
We recommend HomeCraft Gutter Protection for homeowners who want a one-stop shop for their gutter needs.
We recommend LeafGuard for homeowners installing new gutters and guards who want an all-in-one system.
We recommend All American Gutter Protection for homeowners on the East Coast who want a reliable micro-mesh gutter guard.
Promotions
Product Image
Rating Categories
Material & Design
Value
Warranty Coverage
Customer Reviews
Services Offered
Effectiveness
*To determine the average pricing for a 200-linear-foot gutter guard system, we gathered real cost data by surveying 1,000 homeowners who have installed gutter guards. A 200-linear-foot system is the standard size and fits a 2,000-square-foot home.
How Gutter Guards Work
If you want to know more about gutter guards, this video with Kevin O’Connor and Mike Vidulich does an excellent job breaking down exactly how these products work.
The Best Gutter Guard Companies
-
Best Overall:
-
Best Customer Review Scores:
-
Best Add-On Services:
-
Best for Self-Cleaning:
-
Best Deals and Discounts:
How We Selected the Top Gutter Guards
A major part of our gutter guard review process is our objective product testing. We purchased 12 of the most popular brands and installed them on a roof and gutter system model. We tested at least one of each type of gutter guard (mesh, foam, screen, and brush) and prioritized those with the most purchases and customer reviews. This process allowed our team to see how each guard worked in person and understand exactly how to install, remove, and clean them. The brands we tested included the following:
- LeafFilter*
- Raptor by Gutterglove
- Two different models by Waterlock
- GutterStuff
- GutterBrush
- Three products by Amerimax
- A-M Gutter Guard
- Home Intuitions Rolled Guard
- Frost King
*indicates a professionally installed product
We tested each product to assess how it withstood wear and tear, debris, and water. We applied debris such as tree leaves, pine needles, shingle grit, falling objects, and water at different speeds. Gutter guards that blocked the most debris, allowed water to pass through without overflowing, and resisted our stress tests received the most points.
We used testing to verify, correct, or reinforce information gathered from customer reviews and independent research. We relied on available information and customer feedback for products we have not yet tested. If a product was unavailable for testing, we didn’t deduct points from that product or company’s overall score.
Our extensive testing of popular DIY and professionally installed gutter guards revealed the following takeaways:
- Micro-mesh gutter guards perform the best. When made well, micro-mesh is the best type of gutter guard as it blocks the most debris and has the best filtration of every type of guard we tested. We recommend avoiding any guard made from low-quality materials such as plastic, PVC, or foam. These guards consistently break more easily, don’t last as long, and are often just as expensive as high-end DIY products.
- The best DIY brand is Waterlock. Waterlock blocked 90% of debris, only failing to stop small dirt particles. These guards also filtered 85% of the water we applied without overflowing, putting them on par with professionally installed guards. However, Waterlock is much less durable than any professionally installed gutter guard, and we generally recommend going with a professional installer because of their higher-quality product, long-lasting warranties, and additional services.
- Every guard needs to be cleaned. None of the guards we tested completely self-cleaned, regardless of the amount of water or pressure we applied. Even reverse-curve guards, which have superior self-cleaning, require occasional brushing or hosing off.
- Every gutter guard brand was easier to clean than an unprotected system: Gutter guards make cleaning much easier and less frequent. Even gutters with low-end guards are easier to clean than those without any protection. You can clean brands like LeafFilter or LeafGuard by spraying them with a hose or going over them with a leafblower, a much less demanding process than digging out the gunk of a clogged gutter system. Without gutter guards, you’ll need to clean your system at least twice per year. Gutter guards reduce cleaning to once every year or so.
- You don’t always get what you pay for. Low-end products, such as foam and brush gutter guards, can actually be more expensive than high-quality micro-mesh models per linear foot.
- Hidden hangers can present installation problems. If your gutters have hidden hangers—which are internal hangers rather than external ones—you’ll have difficulty installing most DIY gutter guards. For example, we could not push foam guards past the hidden hangers without them snagging. We recommend opting for a professional gutter guard if you have hidden hangers.
We used these testing insights along with our independent research to score each gutter guard on six key factors that reflect what homeowners look for in a reliable gutter guard provider. These factors include material and design, cost, warranty coverage, customer reviews, services offered (or ease of installation for DIY products), and effectiveness, which we detail below.
See how our five top-recommended professional gutter guard companies compare on price versus our overall score in the following chart.
Material & Design
A gutter guard’s material affects how long it lasts and how well it performs. Gutter guards made from lower-quality materials, such as plastic or PVC, deteriorate quickly and perform worse than those made from high-end metals like stainless steel. Additionally, a gutter guard’s design determines how well it can filter out materials while allowing water to pass through. This criterion looks at both of these facets in tandem, assessing each guard based on how it’s made and what it’s made from.
Guards made from longer-lasting, more durable, and corrosion-resistant materials scored higher. Specifically, we awarded more points to guards made from stainless steel, aluminum, and copper, while guards made from PVC, foam, and plastics scored lower. We also considered the guard's construction and overall performance. Guards with a discreet appearance, efficient filter, and sturdy construction were awarded more points.
The standout brand in this category was LeafFilter. LeafFilter uses surgical-grade stainless steel woven into a 275-micron micro-mesh screen. Essentially, it uses one of the best kinds of stainless steel you can buy and makes an ultra-thin membrane out of it. This system is fine enough to keep out particles as small as shingle grit and pollen while still letting water pass through, increasing the chance you won’t need to pay for gutter cleaning services.
Here’s a breakdown of how each guard in this article scored for this factor:
Value
Even if a company offers a high-end product, it isn’t worth investing in if it doesn't treat its customers fairly or hold to industry standards. This category represents how much bang for their buck homeowners get from a gutter guard company. We considered a gutter guard provider's product, performance, and general quality of life bonuses (such as free quotes, discounts, and financing) compared to its cost. The more a company provides for its customers and the lower its price, the more points it earned.
We examined each company's overall offerings by researching its quote process, discounts, financing, product specifications, and installation performance. We then compared the results to the product’s overall price. We obtained our information by reviewing each company’s website, combing through customer reviews, and surveying customers directly.
Overall, most companies on our list performed admirably in this category, with LeafFilter scoring the highest. Though LeafFilter charges slightly more than the industry average, it makes up for it with exceptionally high material quality and a long system life span. Its financing requires purchases of only $1,000 or more with a 0% APR for 24 months, which is highly generous compared to some other brands, like LeafGuard, that require purchases upwards of $7,000. All in all, it provides excellent value for the price.
Here are the value scores for our top gutter guard picks:
Warranty Coverage
Gutter guards are expensive. A strong warranty provides customers with long-term financial protection for their investment. Companies that offer longer-lasting, transferable, and clearly defined warranties earned the most points in this category. The industry average warranty length for a professionally installed guard is the lifetime of the home it's installed on. DIY products typically have warranties ranging from 15–25 years. A gutter guard warranty is generous if it's transferable to new homeowners and has few exclusions.
We also considered whether the warranty offered is a true warranty and not a “no-clog guarantee.” These guarantees are not proper warranties and don’t provide real financial protection. Instead, they’re typically a promise made by the company to come clean or repair your system in case of a clog. These guarantees don’t promise refunds, nor do they cover damages caused by a clog. Companies that offer proper warranties, clearly host their warranty information on their website and provide no-clog guarantees earned more points in this category.
Two companies came out on top regarding warranties: LeafFilter and LeafGuard. LeafFilter has a proper lifetime transferable warranty that promises to replace the product or refund you 100% of the material purchase price for all LeafFilter materials installed on your home. LeafGuard offers two separate warranties, one for its ScratchGuard coating and another for its seamless aluminum gutters. Both warranties last the lifetime of your home and are transferable.
Here is a breakdown of each company's warranty score:
Customer Reviews
One of the best ways to assess any home service company is by reading customer reviews. We used reviews to supplement our extensive in-house research by providing a snapshot of hundreds to thousands of different brand experiences. To ensure we got a holistic and realistic representation of customers’ experiences, we read hundreds of reviews (or as many as there are available) for each company from a wide range of sources. We looked for consistent themes and recurring pain points, noting these problems across review sites to save you time and discover potential problems each company may have.
We looked at independent, third-party review sites such as the Better Business Bureau, Trustpilot, and Google Reviews. We used an average among these sites to score each provider and compared it against satisfaction scores from our survey respondents. We kept each company’s size in mind, as well as the fact that reviews tend to lean negative online. For example, we’re aware that review pages for local companies with fewer responses don’t accurately represent the entire customer experience due to the small sample size. In these cases, it's more likely that only disgruntled customers left reviews, even though many other customers may have had excellent experiences with the smaller provider.
Unlike some other home service industries, gutter guard installers receive relatively strong average customer review scores across the board. Most companies have an average score between 2.5 and 4 out of 5 stars on independent review sites. Some sites, like BBB, skew more negative, but those like Google and Trustpilot have moderately decent ratings. Out of our top picks, LeafFilter, Gutter Guards America, and HomeCraft all scored exceptionally well in this category, receiving strong scores across review sites and impressive satisfaction ratings in our surveys.
Here’s how our top gutter guard companies scored in the customer review category:
Services Offered
Gutter guards are just one part of your home’s drainage system. Any company that installs these products should be able to work on your entire gutter system. As such, companies that offer various gutter-related services earned higher points in this category. Additional services include gutter repair, installation, cleaning, and downspout replacement. We awarded extra points to companies that provide roofing services, such as fascia or soffit repair.
Standouts in this category included LeafFilter, Gutter Guards America, and HomeCraft. Each company offers a host of additional services outside of standard gutter guard installation. We do want to note that LeafFilter’s services are only available when purchasing a system and are not sold independently. However, Gutter Guards America and HomeCraft both offer gutter and roofing services that can be purchased alongside or independently of gutter guard installations.
Here’s how each of our recommended companies scored in this category:
Effectiveness
The effectiveness score represents how well a gutter guard performs and how easy it is to clean. We used a combination of testing results, survey data, and customer reviews to determine each guard's overall performance. We looked at how much debris a guard kept out, how much water it let in, and how easy it was to remove leftover debris. We considered any gutter guard that kept out a majority of debris (80%-99%) while letting in a majority of water (90% or more) under standard conditions to be effective. The more debris that slipped past and the more water that overflowed, the fewer points it earned.
We then compared this information with the general satisfaction ratings from our survey respondents. When gauging customer satisfaction, we used two metrics: general performance and debris filtration. General performance measures all aspects of the guard, such as cleanability and water passability. Debris filtration specifically examines the guard's ability to prevent buildups and stop gutter gunk.
The top-scoring companies in this category were LeafFilter, LeafGuard, and Gutter Guards America. Each product keeps out most materials, lets in water without easily overflowing, and scores above 70% in customer satisfaction.
Here is how each company fared in our effectiveness rating:
Pricing for the Best Gutter Guards
One of the primary questions we heard in our 2024 survey of over 1,000 gutter guard shoppers was “how much can I expect to pay?” While pricing can vary by material and provider, there is less variation between these factors than in many other categories of home repairs. Consumers will often pay between $2,100 and and $2,500 for 2,000 linear feet of gutter guards—this measurement is the average for an American home.
Data is based on our 2024 survey of 1,284 customers who purchased and installed gutter guard systems within the last year, focusing on detailed cost insights specific to the type, size, and provider of the gutter guard system.
Our Top Professional Gutter Guard Picks
After thoroughly analyzing 16 companies, testing 12 brands firsthand, and surveying 1,000 customers, we found that the following companies provide the best gutter guards in the industry.
It’s important to know that during our research, we found many online comments claiming that gutter guards are a scam. We strongly disagree but understand how some customers can come to that conclusion. Many gutter guard brands advertise that you’ll never need to climb a ladder again, leading to the perception that installing gutter guards means you’ll never have to clean your gutters. This simply isn't true. No gutter guard can completely remove the need for regular cleaning, and any gutter guard brand can clog under the right circumstances.
What gutter guards actually do is reduce how often you need to clean your gutters and make the maintenance process easier. Gutters without guards usually need cleaning two or three times per year in areas with heavy foliage. Gutters protected by gutter guards only need cleaning once per year or every other year. On top of that, most gutter guards only need a quick, light brushing to remove materials. Cleaning gutters without guards means using a scoop or your gloved hands to slowly and tediously clear debris.
Best Overall: LeafFilter
What We Liked
- Includes a lifetime transferable warranty instead of a performance guarantee
- Uses stainless steel, a highly durable gutter guard material
- Has some of the highest customer review scores in the industry
What We Didn't Like
- Doesn’t offer additional services beyond gutter guard installations
- Has received negative customer feedback for its aggressive sales tactics
Our Scores
We scored LeafFilter a 4.7 out of 5 stars. It earned the highest points in “Customer Reviews” and “Warranty Coverage.” Its lowest score was in “Material & Design.”
Our Review
We find LeafFilter to be the best overall gutter guard installer. Its gutter guards use a three-piece system incorporating a polyvinyl chloride (PVC) frame, 275-micron stainless steel micro-mesh screen, and reinforcing hangers. Its ultra-fine mesh screen is more durable, easier to clean, and blocks more debris than other brands. We don’t like that it uses PVC, which is more prone to damage and doesn’t last as long as metal materials like aluminum, but its material and build quality are otherwise excellent. It also only uses a small amount of PVC, so the system will still last 25+ years compared to other PVC options that only last 10.
Regarding LeafFilter’s screen, a micron is a unit of measurement that expresses how large something is. For example, human hair is between 75 to 100 microns. This means that LeafFilter’s screen is very fine. However, most gutter guards have fine screens, so calling out micron size is more of a catchy talking point and there’s minimal difference among brands. What really impresses us is how well-constructed LeafFilter’s system is. The frame is tightly set around the filter, there are no gaps in any of its sections, and the guard’s built-in pitch perfectly pushes off debris.
LeafFilter supplied us with a floor model of its system so we could test it firsthand. We noted the following highlights during testing:
- Its durable design and substructure create heightened impact resistance.
- Its fine stainless steel screens is better than other gutter guards at blocking small debris, keeping out even shingle grit and pollen.
- The system filters water without overflowing, even in heavy rain conditions. Other guards, such as Amerimax, overflowed in intense rainfall during our testing.
- It resists clogging and is the easiest to clean of the brands we tested, allowing most debris to slide right off.
We surveyed 130 LeafFilter customers and found that a 200-linear-foot system costs an average of $5,528, or $27.64 per linear foot. This price is in line with the industry average for professionally installed micro-mesh guards. Our respondents were also very happy with their guards’ performance, with 79% saying they were either satisfied or very satisfied.
While most gutter guard companies offer financing options, LeafFilter’s rates are more generous and have lower purchasing requirements. LeafFilter offers financing through Wells Fargo. It requires purchases of $1,000 or more and has 0% APR for 24 months. LeafFilter provides a 10% discount for seniors, veterans, and active-duty military service members. Local branches may have additional deals, so it's always worth asking your sales rep about ongoing promotions.
Our only major issue with LeafFilter is its sales practices. Customers have consistently complained that its representatives quote high prices (within the range of $7,000–$10,000) only to lower them during negotiation. This tactic is common in the gutter guard industry, but LeafFilter got more complaints about it than we typically see, leading us to believe they practice it more than other companies. We recommend negotiating with your sales rep to bring your price within an acceptable range. One of our team members used to work in sales and says the best way to get a better price is to clearly state your budget at the beginning of your conversation with the representative and refuse to go any higher.
Customer Reviews
- Easy to clean
- Great filtration
- Professional representatives
- Aggressive sales tactics
LeafFilter’s customer reviews are some of the strongest in the industry. It has more than 6,000 Better Business Bureau (BBB) reviews, with an average rating of 3.9 out of 5 stars. Its Trustpilot page features more than 123,000 reviews, with an average rating of 4.4 out of 5 stars.
Many customers are pleased with LeafFilter’s gutter guard performance and installation process. They note that LeafFilter’s system easily blocks most debris, including small materials like pine needles and seedpods. Other commenters praise LeafFilter’s polite and professional service techs.
Negative themes include pushy sales tactics and inconsistent installation quality. Some customers say installation crews installed parts incorrectly or failed to clean up job sites properly. Reviewers also note that LeafFilter’s system can worsen ice dams, which are ridges of ice that form on your roof and prevent melting snow from draining off.
We find these issues disappointing but unsurprising. It’s difficult for any large company to maintain consistent installation quality across all locations, and all gutter guards make ice dams worse. You can prevent this by installing heat tape or improving your attic ventilation.
Best Customer Review Scores: Gutter Guards America
15% off new installations
What We Liked
- Is manufactured in the U.S., unlike many gutter guard brands
- Makes filter with corrosion-resistant, surgical-grade stainless steel mesh
- Offers additional services, including seamless gutter installation and roof repair
What We Didn’t Like
- Advertises misleading claim that its guards keep you off ladders
- Doesn’t provide warranty details online, such as exclusions and conditions
Our Scores
We awarded Gutter Guards America 4.5 out of 5 stars. It scored highest in the “Services” and “Customer Reviews” categories and lowest in “Warranty Coverage.”
Our Review
We like GGA’s gutter guards for their unique design and impressive material quality. The company uses a stainless steel micro-mesh screen set into a galvanized steel louvered frame with an aluminum base. This makes it one of the most durable systems out there, on par with LeafGuard.
GGA’s mesh screen has a unique wave-like pattern that helps filter water and push off debris. However, customers experienced pine needle and shingle grit buildup, and we’re concerned that the small gaps created by this pattern are causing this. If you experience smaller debris in your gutters, we recommend a system with a flat, tightly set screen like LeafFilter’s, as it offers better filtration. Most gutter guard brands also offer multiple color options, whereas GGA’s guard only comes in white.
According to the nearly 300 Gutter Guards America customers we surveyed, a 200-linear-foot system costs an average of $5,270, or $26.35 per linear foot. This range aligns with industry-standard pricing for this gutter guard type. Like most gutter guard companies, Gutter Guards America offers financing through monthly payment plans. It promises 18-month, 0% interest rates to qualifying customers. It also provides several discounts, including the following:
- 15% general discount on purchases and installations
- 10% discount for seniors, military personnel, veterans, and first responders
Our survey results showed that GGA customers are happy with their systems’ performance, with 89% of respondents saying they were satisfied. This satisfaction rate is 10% higher than any other company on our list. The company’s impressive reviews on third-party sites like Trustpilot back up our findings, so we awarded it high points in our customer reviews and value categories.
Our biggest issue with GGA is its claim that it can keep you off a ladder. This might be true if you live in a one-story home with no surrounding trees, but we don’t believe this is the norm for most customers. As we mentioned earlier, you’ll need to clean your gutters every year or so even with a product like GGA, so you won’t be completely free from ladders.
Customer Reviews
- Professional technicians
- Polite representatives
- Effective products
- Inconsistent quality
Gutter Guards America has an overall positive reputation among customers. Though it has a low score of 2.5 out of 5 stars on BBB, this is only based on two reviews, which we don’t view as a meaningful sample size. Its Trustpilot page has nearly 600 reviews with an average score of 4.5 out of 5 stars, which is more reassuring. The feedback is mostly positive, with many customers praising GGA’s speedy installations and skilled technicians. We also contacted GGA ourselves to gauge its customer service reps’ helpfulness and found them to be polite and knowledgeable. They informed us the company uses seamless aluminum gutters and offers various gutter and roofing services.
Negative reviews are uncommon, but those we did find mention inconsistent installation quality and high costs. Specifically, disgruntled customers note a trend of incomplete or poor-quality jobs. For example, a negative review on Trustpilot detailed a faulty installation involving poor-quality materials. The GGA team wanted to use unpainted wood for the installation, but the customer noted this would lead to rot, resulting in a back and forth with GGA’s office to get the issue resolved. We agree using unpainted wood would lead to rot and mildew due to constant exposure to the elements. Thankfully, the local branch agreed to paint over the exposed timber.
Best Add-On Services: HomeCraft Gutter Protection
New customers save 30%
What We Liked
- Has a unique raised-screen design for improved debris filtration
- Is a family-owned and operated business, unlike many national brands
- Offers a host of gutter services, including repairs and installations
What We Didn't Like
- Reviews indicate occasionally poor communication post-installation
- No pricing information online
Our Scores
We awarded HomeCraft 4.2 out of 5 stars. It scored high in “Value” and “Customer Reviews” but lower in “Warranty Coverage.”
Our Review
We like HomeCraft Gutter Protection’s wide selection of services and impressive products. The company offers customers a one-stop shop for gutter services, including cleaning, repairs, and replacements. Most gutter guard companies only offer gutter guard installations and occasionally gutter replacement. This earned HomeCraft maximum points in the services category.
HomeCraft’s gutter guard uses a 304-marine grade stainless steel filter, powder-coated aluminum frame, and reinforcing hangers. Marine-grade stainless steel is an alloy that combines steel's strength and durability with chromium's corrosion resistance, making it highly resistant to weather and rust. Powder-coated aluminum, while not as strong as stainless steel, provides good durability and long-term weather resistance. Its built-in pitch and design help reduce future gutter maintenance and cleaning difficulty. Overall, a metal system like HomeCraft’s is a sound, long-term investment that will last 25 years or more, while systems made of lower-end materials like PVC will need replacing in 10 years.
HomeCraft’s screen features an indented diamond pattern called “raised screen technology.” We’re skeptical about how much the screen’s pattern helps water flow, but its design is aesthetically pleasing and gives the system a unique look. Regardless, HomeCraft uses top-tier materials and earns a respectable score of 4 out of 5 stars in the materials and design category. It lost a single point due to its lack of customization options compared to Leaffilter and Leafguard.
According to the 100 HomeCraft customers we surveyed, a 200-linear-foot system costs an average of $6,338, or $31.69 per linear foot. We’re not fans of this price. Our research found that the average cost of a professionally installed gutter guard is around $4,300, making HomeCraft $2,000 (just under 30%) more expensive than similar systems.
HomeCraft’s website states it offers financing through a third-party lender. Though more expensive than the industry average, we still think HomeCraft is worth considering due to its durability, longevity, and wide service selection.
Customer Reviews
- Attentive representatives
- Prompt technicians
- Easy-to-clean guard
- Poor communication
HomeCraft’s BBB page has nearly 100 reviews, averaging 2.35 out of 5 stars. Its Trustpilot page has around 250 reviews with a 4.4 out of 5 star average. Customers praise HomeCraft’s family-owned business mentality and polite, knowledgeable sales reps. Reviewers also compliment the prompt, attentive technicians and installation crews. We called HomeCraft's customer service line ourselves, and the associate we spoke to was polite and helpful. We were curious about its system's lack of substructure and asked what benefit this design provided. The associate explained that this lack of support system makes HomeCraft more compatible with some roof systems, specifically metal roofs.
Most negative reviewers mention frustrations with HomeCraft’s post-installation communication. For example, one customer claimed they sent 12 emails and made multiple phone calls with no response. Unfortunately, we’ve found that poor communication after installation is one of the most common complaints across the home service industry.
Best for Self-Cleaning: LeafGuard
20% off your purchase
What We Liked
- Resists clogs and buildup better than other brands
- Features a sturdy, single-piece reverse-curve design
- Includes a ScratchGuard paint finish that increases weather resistance
What We Didn't Like
- Requires gutter replacement, whereas other companies install guards on existing gutters
- Doesn’t provide pricing information online, a standard in the industry
Our Scores
LeafGuard earned a score of 4.1 out of 5 stars. It did well in “Warranty Coverage” and “Effectiveness” but lost points in “Materials & Design.”
Our Review
LeafGuard has the most impressive self-cleaning of all the brands we reviewed, meaning you’ll need to clean your gutters even less than with other guards. Unlike other companies that install gutter guards on your existing gutters, LeafGuard also combines its gutters and gutter guards into an all-in-one system, offering good value if you need to install both at the same time.
LeafGuard uses an all-aluminum seamless gutter and a reverse-curve gutter helmet. Reverse-curve systems use the scientific principles of surface tension to allow water to flow through while pushing debris off, whereas the flat filter on micro-mesh guards can cause debris to build up on top. This is what makes LeafGuard’s self-cleaning so good. Its system is also coated in ScratchGuard paint, allowing it to resist scratches and harsher weather conditions. Though its aluminum frame doesn’t last as long as stainless steel options, LeafGuard’s system is still one of the most durable on the market.
Our main issue with LeafGuard is that it performs poorly in heavy rainfall and cold weather, leading to overflows and ice dams. Reverse-curve guards don’t work well in heavy rain because they have a smaller opening for water, and their angled cap can cause water to flow right past the system. We recommend LeafGuard for homeowners who want to clean their gutters as little as possible and don’t live in areas with heavy rainfall, such as Washington and New York. Choose a different type of gutter guard, such as a micro-mesh or perforated screen system, if you live in an area like this.
Based on the data we gathered in our homeowner survey and from customer reviews, LeafGuard’s system costs between $4,000 and $10,000, with an average of $7,900. LeafGuard’s cost and financing page backs this up. LeafGuard works with Synchrony Bank to provide 132-month financing at $99 per month. It requires a payment of $7,883 to qualify for financing plans, implying that its systems fall around this price. A $7,900 price tag may seem high, but remember that this is an all-in-one system, so you're getting a seamless aluminum gutter installation along with your new guards. For context, seamless aluminum gutters cost $3,400 on average, and the lowest guard installation price on our list is $4,150, which would be $7,550 combined. We still think LeafGuard charges slightly too much, but its efficient performance and reliable financing provide good value overall.
Customer Reviews
- Prompt technicians
- Polite representatives
- High durability
- High cost
LeafGuard has mixed customer reviews on BBB and Trustpilot. Its BBB page has 160 reviews with 1.5 out of 5 stars. Its Trustpilot page has 44 reviews with 2.2 out of 5 stars. Because of these less-than-impressive scores, we rated LeafGuard 3.3 out of 5 in the customer review category.
The majority of LeafGuard’s negative comments point toward aggressive sales tactics, high costs, and poor performance in heavy rainfall, which is in line with our own findings. Most reviews that cite high product costs reveal prices of $7,000 or more, with some reaching over $10,000. Again, LeafGuard is an all-in-one gutter and gutter guard system. The higher price makes sense compared to other brands that only install gutter guards, but it’s still above the industry average.
Positive comments cite LeafGuard’s prompt service technicians, polite customer representatives, and impressively durable system. Overall, most positive-reviewing customers are pleased with LeafGuard’s self-cleaning and efficiency, noting that the system rarely needs maintenance and keeps most debris out.
Best Deals and Discounts: All American Gutter Protection
What We Liked
- Provides extra impact resistance from falling trees, hail, and other objects
- Offers seamless aluminum gutters in 30 colors
- Has more discounts than other gutter guard companies
What We Didn't Like
- Doesn’t offer gutter cleaning or repair services
- Has a lower satisfaction rating than other companies
Our Scores
All American earned a score of 3.9 out of 5 stars. It scored best in the “Material & Design” and “Value” categories but lower in “Services.”
Our Review
All American Gutter Protection has one of the most uniquely designed guards we’ve come across. Like LeafFilter and Homecraft, the company provides a micro-mesh gutter guard. However, All American’s guards have an extra-wide substructure that is as large as some DIY guards. We think this design has both benefits and downsides.
The stainless steel micro-mesh screen is able to block small debris, such as pine needles and shingle grit. The extra-wide substructure increases the screen's impact resistance and overall durability. This guard basically has two protection systems stacked on top of each other, providing twice the protection. However, the amount of space for water to flow into the system is greatly reduced, possibly leading to overflows in heavy rainfall. The guard also boasts an all-aluminum frame. Many other guards use PVC as connectors or frame components, creating structural weak points. An all-aluminum frame removes this problem. Because of these mostly positive product qualities, All American earned a score of 4 out of 5 in the materials and design category.
Another quality we like about All American is its gutter installation services. It offers seamless aluminum gutters in over 30 colors. We wish All American offered more services like gutter cleaning, downspout installation, and fascia repair so you don’t have to call multiple contractors, but its wide selection of colors is a nice inclusion. Due to this lack of additional services, we only awarded it 2 out of 5 stars in the services category.
According to 200 All American customers we surveyed, the average price for one of the company’s gutter guard systems is $5,868. This is slightly more expensive than the industry average, but we think the quality of All America’s product is worth it. A stainless steel guard with an all-aluminum frame should last 20 years or more in ideal conditions, making this system a good investment. We also like All American’s financing and discounts. It offers financing through Wells Fargo for customers with approved credit. Additionally, it has more discounts than other providers. Most gutter guard companies only provide basic senior and military discounts, whereas All American has these options plus a $300 off program and 20% off if you purchase guards for your entire home.
Customer Reviews
- Durable guard
- Skilled technicians
- Polite representatives
- Mixed reviews
Unfortunately, All American Gutter Protection has very few online reviews. The company only has a single review on Trustpilot. There’s a little more to work with on BBB, where All American has 49 reviews and an average score of 3.2 out of 5 stars. Common highlights include polite representatives and an effective product. However, some customers complain about poor communication, dropped appointments, rescheduling, and other customer service issues. For example, one frustrated customer says they scheduled an appointment, the technicians didn’t show up, and then they had to wait a month for a callback only for All American to cancel the order.
We don’t believe the comments on the BBB present a large enough sample size to properly represent the experience of working with All American. Our survey revealed some additional insights. Of our 200 respondents, 71% were either satisfied or very satisfied with their gutter guards’ performance. These scores fall in line with those of other gutter guard companies we surveyed, with the average being 72.6% overall satisfaction. We believe All American Gutter Protection offers a fine product, but it could improve in some areas of its customer service.
Compare Our Top 5 DIY Gutter Guard Companies
The table below compares all the DIY gutter guards we reviewed based on performance, price, and other key factors. Even if we don’t generally recommend a brand, it may still be right for your home or the problem you’re facing. For example, GutterBrush’s design and material quality come up short compared to other brands we reviewed. However, it's extremely easy to install and may work if you want a quick and easy fix, which is why we recommend it over other options that scored slightly higher in our review standards.
Filter Type
Sample Price
Warranty Length
Pros
- Lifetime, transferable warranty
- Stainless steel micro-mesh guard that blocks small debris
- High customer review scores
- Compatible with multiple roof and gutter types
- Aluminum and stainless steel system lasts longer than PVC
- Micro-mesh screen blocks small debris like shingle grit
- Extra-thick, high-gauge aluminum screen resists dents
- All-aluminum system that’s corrosion-resistant and good for all climates
- Easy to install over most gutter types
- Easy-to-install system that snaps into K-style guards
- Mesh screen that stops medium and large debris
- Screen doesn’t overflow even in downpours
- Easiest product to install on this list
- Blocks medium and large debris
- Works with all roof and gutter systems
- Lowest cost per linear foot on this list
- Blocks medium-sized debris
- Easy to install and fasten to gutter system
- Lowest cost of the brands we reviewed
- Blocks medium-sized debris
- Micro-mesh screen blocks small debris like shingle grit
- 100% aluminum system that's corrosion resistant
- Thick-gauge screen is resistant to impacts
- Includes a lifetime warranty
- Easily modifiable to fit gutter system
- Blocks small debris like shingle grit
- Easy to install on some gutter systems
- Low cost
- Blocks small debris like pine needles
- Easy to install and fasten to gutters
- Low cost
- Lightweight
- Easy to install and fasten to gutters
Cons
- Heavy frame that won’t fit every gutter and roof type
- Most expensive DIY guard in this article
- Difficult-to-cut screen, which impacts installation
- Fine mesh results in occasional overflows and ice-overs
- Fails to block small debris like pine needles and seedpods
- Overflowed in heavy downpour conditions
- Completely fails to block small debris like pine needles
- Powder coated-steel may rust over time
- System is designed to clog, requiring more upkeep
- Won’t prevent pest or bird infestations in gutters
- Plastic material degrades more quickly than metal guards
- Relatively flimsy product that’s easy to damage or break
- Plastic material degrades more quickly than metal guards
- Relatively flimsy product that’s easy to damage or break
- Can't handle heavy water flow
- Won't easily fit onto nonstandard gutters
- Material breaks down in UV rays
- Won't fit easily on systems with hidden hangers
- Plastic material degrades more quickly than metal guards
- Plastic screen is exceptionally low quality and overflows often
- Guard is thick and easily bendable
- Holes in the front of the guard are too small, causing overflows
Summary
We recommend Waterlock micro-mesh guards for homeowners who want a high-end DIY guard that blocks pine needles, seedpods, and leaves.
We recommend Raptor for its well-made micro-mesh screen that blocks small debris. It’s easy to modify for homeowners who have nonstandard roofs or gutters.
We recommend A-M’s aluminum gutter guard for its high-end all-aluminum screen that blocks medium-sized debris and withstands heavy impacts.
We recommend Amerimax’s lock-in mesh guard for homeowners in climates with heavy rain. Its mesh screen can withstand heavy downpours.
We recommend GutterBrush for homeowners who want an easy and fast installation and don’t mind a less effective guard that will require more maintenance than other products.
We recommend Frost King’s guard for homeowners with long gutter systems. Its low price allows you to protect larger systems for a lower price.
We recommend Home Intuition for homeowners with long gutter systems who want an easy installation. Its low price allows you to protect larger systems cheaply and quickly.
We don’t recommend Waterlock Pro due to its poor performance compared to its high price.
We don’t recommend GutterFoam due to its low material quality and high relative cost.
We don’t recommend Amerimax’s micro-mesh guard due to its constant overflows and poor material quality.
We don’t recommend Amerimax’s reverse-curve guard because of its inability to filter water without overflowing.
Product Image
Rating Categories
Material & Design
Value
Warranty Coverage
Customer Reviews
Ease of Installation
Effectiveness
Our Top-Rated DIY Gutter Guard Products
-
Best DIY Guard:
-
Best for Nonstandard Roofs:
-
Best for the Environment:
-
Best for Heavy Rainfall:
-
Best for Easy Installations:
How We Selected the Top DIY Gutter Guards
We assessed each DIY guard using firsthand testing and customer reviews. Our rating system considered the criteria homeowners find most important, including material and design, value, warranty coverage, customer reviews, ease of installation, and effectiveness.
Material & Design
DIY guards are mass-manufactured and must be installed by regular homeowners, so it’s important that they’re built intuitively and use materials that won’t be easily damaged during installation. As with professional guards, we scored micro-mesh products made from high-end materials like stainless steel or aluminum the highest because they last longer and block more debris. We scored foam and brush guards the lowest because they clog easily and are harder to clean, though these may appeal to some homeowners because they’re exceptionally easy to install.
Waterlock and Raptor scored the highest in this category. Both brands use a micro-mesh screen and high-end materials but different designs. Waterlock has a thicker frame, making it more durable than other guards and allowing it to withstand harsh weather conditions. Raptor uses a thinner, more malleable frame so you can customize the product more easily to your roof. As such, we recommend Waterlock for standard roofs and Raptor for alternative roofs, such as those with metal shingles or steep slopes.
Here’s a breakdown of how each DIY guard scored for this factor:
Value
Some brands offer more bang for your buck at a slightly higher price. For this category, we compared the cost of a 200-linear-foot system with quality of life bonuses including multiple communication methods, discounts, instruction manuals, and online resources. Guards that offered the most benefits for the lowest price rated highest.
Most products in this article had middling scores ranging from 3 to 4.5. Raptor earned the most points due to its impressive instruction manual, comprehensive online guides, and 25-year warranty. Waterlock was a close second, but Raptor is half the price. Frost King and Home Intuition also rated high in this category because they’re very cheap and offer all of the extra benefits outlined above, but they didn’t make our top five because they don’t perform as well as other brands we reviewed.
Here are the value scores for our top picks:
Warranty Coverage
Unfortunately, problems like damaged products, missing pieces, and incorrectly sized components are common for DIY guards. A good warranty helps to financially protect you in these cases, as well as from product failures that may occur over time. Products with longer-lasting, transferable, and clearly defined warranties earned the most points in this category. The average warranty length for DIY gutter guards is 15–25 years. We consider a gutter guard warranty to be generous if it lasts 25 years or longer—especially if it lasts for the lifetime of your home.
The best-performing products in this category were Waterlock and A-M Aluminum. Waterlock and A-M both offer a lifetime transferable warranty, something almost unheard of for DIY gutter guards. Raptor was runner-up in this category, providing an above-average 25-year warranty.
Here’s a breakdown of each company's warranty score:
Customer Reviews
We read customer reviews to compare our testing results to other consumers’ experiences. Most DIY gutter guards are sold exclusively on Amazon, but we also read reviews on retailer sites such as Lowe’s and Home Depot when available. We noted consistent positive and negative themes to get a sense of each product’s performance and any problems customers have encountered.
Gutter guards generally have strong customer review scores on Amazon. Most items have an average score of 4.5 out of 5 stars on their respective pages. Even guards we believe should receive lower scores, such as GutterBrush and GutterFoam, have high Amazon ratings and appear to be well-received online. Waterlock, Raptor, A-M Aluminum, and Amerimax all scored highest in this category. We agree with their impressive overall customer review scores.
Here’s how our top DIY gutter guards scored in this category:
Ease of Installation
It doesn't matter how well a gutter guard performs if it’s a nightmare to install. This category looked at each guard's overall installation process and the instructional materials that come with it.
If a guard was light, easy to handle, safe, and accompanied by an easy-to-understand instruction booklet, it earned high points. Guards that were difficult or dangerous to install lost points. For example, guards that had sharp edges or overly cumbersome designs didn’t perform well in this category. While most guards were relatively easy to install, GutterBrush far outperformed the other guards in this category. Its simple, slide-in design made installation quick.
Home Intuition and Frost King also scored high in this category because they’re easy to install: they both roll onto your gutters and have clips that snap them down. However, as mentioned, their quality is lacking compared to other brands.
Here’s how each of our recommended products scored in this category:
Effectiveness
We looked at how well each guard blocked debris, if it overflowed, and how easy it was to clean. We consider any gutter guard that blocks 80%–99% of debris while letting in 90% or more water without overflowing within standard conditions to be effective. The poorer it performed in each of the categories, the more points it lost.
The best guards in this category were Waterlock, Raptor, and A-M Aluminum. Each product blocked more than 85% of debris, filtered water without easily overflowing, and was easy to clean.
Here’s how each company fared in our effectiveness rating:
Our Top DIY Gutter Guard Picks
After installing and rigorously testing 11 DIY gutter guards, we found the following products to be the best-performing, most reasonably priced, and highest-rated. While we think these guards perform worse than professionally installed options—for example, LeafFilter’s stainless steel micro-mesh guard—they still offer reliable gutter protection for DIY-minded homeowners.
Realistically, professionally installed guards provide better filtration, longer-lasting warranties, and additional services such as gutter and downspout installation. Putting DIY gutter guards on your home can also damage your gutter and roof system, and you risk serious injury due to the ladder work required. However, the average cost of a professional gutter guard is around $4,760—four times pricier than the most expensive guard on this list.
Many homeowners are willing to apply a little elbow grease to install a decent product if it means saving thousands of dollars. That said, you’ll need the appropriate skills, tools, and experience to install DIY gutter guards properly. At a minimum, you’ll need to be comfortable working on a ladder and have the following tools:
- Ladder
- Ladder stabilizer (optional but recommended)
- Personal protective equipment (PPE), such as safety glasses
- Screw gun
- Self-tapping screws
- Thick, protective gloves
- Tin snips
- Tool belt
Best DIY Guard: Waterlock Micro-Mesh Guard
What We Liked
- Includes a lifetime transferable warranty, which is uncommon for DIY guards
- Uses a stainless steel mesh screen, a durable and corrosion-resistant metal
- Withstands medium to heavy rainfall while still blocking small debris
What We Didn't Like
- Has a thick frame that makes handling the product difficult
- May not fit nonstandard gutters, such as half-round gutters
Our Scores
We awarded Waterlock 4.5 out of 5 stars. It earned the most points in “Customer Reviews” and “Warranty Coverage.” Its lowest score was in “Ease of Installation.”
Our Review
We think Waterlock’s micro-mesh gutter guard is the best DIY option on the market. Its micro-mesh filter performed the best during testing, blocking more debris than any other product. It also comes in 14 colors to match your home’s aesthetic.
Waterlock’s guard is sturdier and more durable than other DIY products thanks to its extra-thick .027 gauge aluminum frame and supporting substructure. For comparison, the standard thickness of aluminum gutters is .019 to .025. Waterlock’s increased thickness puts it in line with professional-quality gutter guard products. The guard shouldn’t bend, warp, or break—even if you experience harsh weather such as hailstorms.
Waterlock’s screen is made of stainless steel and woven into a tight mesh. During testing, it kept out leaves, pine needles, twigs, shingle grit, and other small particles. We believe this guard will keep debris out of your gutter system and save you time and effort in future maintenance.
Our only major issue with Waterlock is its price. Most DIY guards cost between $200 and $600 for enough materials to cover a 200-linear-foot system. Waterlock costs more than $1,000 for that amount of material. However, it’s made from corrosion-resistant metals (aluminum) and can last 15–20 years or more, making it a valuable long-term investment. Combined with its impressive performance and lifetime warranty, it still earned a strong score in the value category even with its higher-than-average price.
Customer Reviews
- Highly durable
- Self-cleans
- Great filtration
- Mixed compatibility
Waterlock’s micro-mesh guard has more than 500 reviews and 4.7 out of 5 stars on Amazon. This is a smaller pool of reviews compared to other DIY gutter guards, but we think 500 reviews is an adequate sample size. Customers say that Waterlock keeps debris out of their systems, reduces gutter cleaning time, and isn’t hard to install. One customer noted that the product worked well throughout the “heavy leaf season of fall.”
Our testing revealed similar results. Waterlock is great at blocking debris, and the smooth surface allows it to push leaves to the ground. Pine needles sometimes get stuck between the screen and filter and need to be removed. Like all gutter guards, you’ll still need to clean Waterlock’s system occasionally.
The negative reviews we read mostly complain that the guard doesn’t fit every gutter type. Specifically, customers who have gutters with nail and ferrule hangers say the guards are incompatible with their systems. Nail and ferrule hangers are internal hangers that use a tube (the ferrule) that runs along the inside of the gutter instead of fastening to the bottom of the system, as with standard hangers. We found that Waterlock was also incompatible with certain internal hangers.
Best for Nonstandard Roofs: Raptor by Gutterglove
No current offers available.
What We Liked
- Uses a tightly woven frame that keeps out small debris
- Easy to adjust to nonstandard gutter and roof systems
- Includes a highly detailed manual that makes installation easier
What We Didn't Like
- Has a thin and easily damageable filter
- Requires more work to install than other DIY guards
Our Scores
Raptor earned 4.3 out of 5 stars. It scored highest in “Customer Reviews” and “Effectiveness.” Its lowest score was in “Warranty Coverage.”
Our Review
Raptor Gutter Guard is a close runner-up to Waterlock. Like Waterlock, it uses a stainless steel micro-mesh screen set in an all-aluminum frame. Both guards perform almost identically when it comes to debris filtration. Raptor blocked all materials during testing, so it should easily keep pine needles, leaves, seedpods, and shingle grit out of your gutters.
Raptor’s frame is notably thinner than Waterlock’s, which makes Raptor’s system slightly more flimsy. We noted how easy it was to warp or accidentally damage the guard during testing. However, this thinner material makes adapting the guard to nonstandard gutter and roof systems easier. For example, our roof model had a slightly steeper pitch than a standard home, and we could alter the system to fit correctly.
Raptor’s lack of substructure makes it more compatible with different roofs but less durable. During testing, we pelted the system with small stones, branches, and other debris. Guards like Waterlock withstood this without any noticeable or serious damage, but Raptor had a dent on its mesh screen. While this didn't prevent it from filtering debris, we suspect a serious hail storm could damage the system. If you live in an area with extreme weather, we recommend a more durable system like Waterlock.
We like Raptor’s $625 price, which puts it in line with other high-end DIY guards. Its 25-year manufacturer's warranty is less impressive than Waterlock’s, but it's still on the higher end of the industry average of 15–25 years. Ultimately, we recommend Raptor for homeowners with nonstandard roofs, such as metal, slate, clay tile, and flat roofs or roofs with steep pitches.
Customer Reviews
- Effective screen
- Malleable frame
- Comprehensive manual
- Tinkering required
Raptor’s Amazon page has more than 5,100 reviews, with a score of 4.5 out of 5 stars. Reviews are overall positive, with most people complimenting the product's high-quality materials, reliable performance, and impressive appearance. Our experience matches most customers. We found the system easy to install, effective at keeping out debris, and easy to clean.
Negative comments mention issues with ice dams and the product’s frame. While we couldn’t replicate the ice dam issue, we did find that Raptor’s frame sizing was a problem. As one customer pointed out, the system's frame extends past the screen by several inches. They had to snip their system down to size and use other tricks to get the system to fit properly. We also had to cut each end down to size so the sections fit flush with one another.
Best for the Environment: A-M Aluminum
What We Liked
- Uses high-gauge aluminum that’s thicker and more durable than other DIY guards
- Features a flat, sleek surface that makes cleaning a breeze
- Has a lifetime warranty, unlike many DIY guards
What We Didn't Like
- Overflows in heavy downpours
- Fails to block pine needles and seed pods
Our Scores
A-M earned a score of 4.2 out of 5 stars. It did well in “Warranty Coverage” and “Value” but scored poorly in “Ease of Installation.”
Our Review
A-M uses high-grade, .018-gauge aluminum, which is thinner than Waterlock’s frame. Unlike micro-mesh guards, which resemble a sieve or strainer, A-M’s gutter guard is basically a metal sheet with holes. This design means that it can’t block materials like pine needles or shingle grit since the guards lack the fine filtration of micro-mesh. On the plus side, the slick, flat metal sheet allows debris to roll off more easily and provides a protective shell for your gutters.
We also like A-M’s warranty. Most DIY guards have a 10-year parts warranty at best. A-M provides a lifetime warranty that promises the product will not rust, rot, or deteriorate. This warranty is generous by DIY standards.
A-M is reasonably priced at $264, more than half the price of Raptor and nearly a quarter the price of Waterlock. The biggest downside to A-M is its installation process. A-M is designed only for K-style gutters and is difficult to modify for nonstandard roofs. During testing, we had a hard time getting the guard to fit correctly on our roof because of its thick aluminum frame and overall rigidity. Because of this, we docked points in the “Ease of Installation” category.
Overall, we recommend A-M for homeowners who need a lower-cost but still highly efficient system that’s easy to clean. We recommend looking at other products if you deal with pine needles or have a nonstandard gutter system.
Customer Reviews
- Doesn't overflow
- Easy installations
- Inexpensive
- Low-quality parts
A-M’s Amazon page has 5,160 reviews with a score of 4.6 out of 5 stars. Commenters praise A-M’s performance, specifically citing its ease of cleaning. For example, one reviewer noted the product was easy to install and blocked debris from their nearby tree. They claimed that the guards were functionally maintenance-free once installed.
Our testing mirrors customers' experiences, aside from the installation. While the majority of customers said the system was a breeze to install, we encountered some difficulty. However, these problems may have been caused by our system's steep roof pitch. Otherwise, we agree with the majority of customers about this guard’s performance and quality.
As noted by multiple other customers, A-M’s guard does a particularly good job blocking and shedding tree leaves. This means it’s one of the easiest to clean and maintain in the long run, saving you time and effort, especially if you live in a leafy area.
Best for Heavy Rainfall: Amerimax Mesh Guard
No current offers available.
What We Liked
- Doesn’t overflow even in heavy downpours
- Snaps right into the gutter system for fast installations
- Is easy to snip and adjust to match your gutter system
What We Didn't Like
- Completely fails to block small materials like shingle grit
- Requires gloves to handle sharp edges
Our Scores
We gave Amerimax 3.9 out of 5 stars. It received high scores in “Customer Reviews” and “Value” but did poorly in the “Warranty Coverage” category.
Our Review
Amerimax’s screen guards use powder-coated steel and a lock-in design. Powder-coated steel is less corrosion-resistant than aluminum and stainless steel and can require replacing after 10 years or so, resulting in a lower score for “Materials & Design.”
Amerimax’s curved lock-in design makes it one of the easiest to install, slotting into K-style gutters. During testing, the guard fit into the gutter easily and locked into place. We recommend using a few screws for a more secure hold, as the system can be jostled loose.
The wideness of this system’s holes means it won’t overflow even in heavy downpours. During testing, we were impressed at how much water passed through, even when the guard was covered in debris. However, while these guards block medium and large debris, they completely fail to keep out small materials like seedpods, pine needles, and shingle grit. We recommend these guards if you live in an area with heavy rainfall and don’t have pine trees.
Amerimax’s warranty is disappointing. It only provides a 10-year part warranty, which offers little protection. However, its very low cost helps compensate for this. You’ll only need to pay $150 to cover an entire 200-linear foot gutter system, a fraction of the cost of higher-end DIY guards.
Customer Reviews
- Doesn't overflow
- Easy installations
- Inexpensive
- Low-quality parts
The customer reviews on Amerimax’s Amazon page are positive, with 4.6 out of 5 stars and more than 1,600 reviews. Positive comments compliment the guard's ability to stop debris. For example, one customer says the guards kept leaves out during fall and withstood snowfall in winter.
Negative comments highlight three major problems with these guards:
- They don't stop small debris.
- They don’t fit on nonstandard gutters.
- The company sends out incorrectly sized packs.
Of these issues, the most prominent is pack size. Customers complain that the company didn’t send the correct number of guards in a pack, with some receiving half or less than the amount they ordered. When we ordered the guards, they were all accounted for and arrived on time. However, some of the guards did have small cuts or other superficial damage.
Best for Easy Installations: GutterBrush
Join Email List For 10% Off
What We Liked
- Doesn’t overflow even in heavy downpours
- Slides right into gutters for fast and easy installations
- Fits most gutter systems
What We Didn't Like
- Is designed to clog and needs more upkeep
- Fails to stop small debris
Our Scores
We awarded GutterBrush 3.5 out of 5 stars. It received high scores in “Customer Reviews” and “Ease of Installation” but low marks in “Warranty Coverage.”
Our Review
GutterBrush is easily the most unique gutter guard we reviewed. Instead of being a protective filter that sits atop your gutters, it’s a long, pipe-cleaner-like structure that sits within them. Its bristles catch and block medium and large debris, keeping them out of your gutters while still letting water pass. To be frank, it’s the worst-performing guard on this list, but it may be the best option for specific situations.
GutterBrush is exceptionally good in two areas: water flow and ease of installation. Since there’s no solid filter blocking the gutter system, water passes right through. It’s also the easiest guard to install because it’s basically a big pipe cleaner, allowing you to simply slide it into your gutters.
We want to stress that GutterBrush falls short compared to every other guard we tested. Three brands technically scored higher in our review standards: Frost King, Home Intuition, and Waterlock Pro. These brands use plastic and aluminum materials along with screen or reverse-curve designs, making them slightly more durable. GutterBrush’s materials are low-end plastics that won't last long—anywhere from one to five years. Its warranty is only 10 years, and debris catching on the bristles will clog your gutters, requiring frequent cleaning.
Still, we think GutterBrush’s above-average filtration sets it apart as the best “quick and easy” fix. Its price is also relatively reasonable at $600 to cover a 200-linear-foot system. If you want something cheap, don’t have much experience working on gutters, and aren’t too picky about performance, GutterBrush is a decent option.
Customer Reviews
- Easy installations
- Relatively cheap
- Quick installations
- Poor quality
GutterBrush’s Amazon page has just under 1,000 reviews and an impressive average rating of 4.7 out of 5 stars. Customers acknowledge this guard’s downsides but praise it for accomplishing its purpose as a cheap and easy-to-install option.
For example, one user awarded the guard a five-star rating and titled the review, “No solution is 100%. These are most effective for me.” They said the other guards they tried failed and that these were the easiest products to replace. They also noted that the guards are more susceptible to bird damage. The customer had issues with chickadees breaking off bristles to use as nesting material.
Most reviews we read agreed that the guards aren’t perfect, but they’re good enough. We can understand these sentiments, but we recommend a higher-quality guard like Waterlock, Raptor, or A-M if you’re looking for a more reliable and longer-lasting product.
To share feedback or ask a question about this article, send a note to our Reviews Team at reviews@thisoldhousereviews.com.